The Blurb

blackhouseFrom acclaimed author and dramatist Peter May comes the Barry award-winning The Blackhouse , the first book in the Lewis Trilogy–a riveting mystery series set on the Isle of Lewis in Scotland’s Outer Hebrides.
When a grisly murder occurs on the Isle of Lewis that bears similarities to a brutal killing on the mainland, Edinburgh detective and native islander Fin Macleod is dispatched to the Outer Hebrides to investigate, embarking at the same time on a voyage into his own troubled past.
As Fin reconnects with the people and places of his tortured childhood, the desolate but beautiful island and its ancient customs once again begin to assert their grip on his psyche. Every step toward solving the case brings Fin closer to a dangerous confrontation with the dark events of the past that shaped–and nearly destroyed–his life.

My Review

This was a book I’d been looking forward to reading for some time, and recommended to my bookclub–so it’ll be interesting to see what the others thought!

The blurb pretty much says it all, but the mention of the word ‘grisly’ does little to prepare you for the double onslaught of a detailed description of a body hanging up with its abdomen cut open and innards hanging out… followed by the detailed description of the autopsy.  Police procedural it is not, despite all that. Having blunted my senses, they failed to re-engage for the rest of the book.

It was disconcerting early on to switch between Fin in the present (third person) and Fin in his memories (first person) although when the memories went back to his childhood it became easier.  I’ve not been to Lewis, although I’ve been to other Hebridean islands and I’ve worked with a Lewis man, so I have a certain affinity for the place, and the author describes it perfectly.  I did wonder how he came to describe the isolated rock on which the gannets nest in so much detail, and the events that take place on that rock, but he does thank the islanders in his end-matter, so the rest is just skill.  The question whether the plot really hangs together is one I would prefer to duck.  I don’t think it does; although I rather suspected the twist at the end a long time before.  I’m just not sure it’s a story that just didn’t want to wallow in misery piled on top of misery.  And one comment he articulated I highlighted with extreme anger–let’s just say I think he’s very blinkered if he thinks that. I could think of other words, mind.

So, far from looking forward to the next in the series, I’ll be happy never to read another Peter May book in my life.  But his descriptions are vivid.

Oh, and if you’re thinking of buying the 501-page paperback, be aware that at least the first four chapters of book 2 are included at the end.  I hate that.  You may think it’s great value for money – but where do you start the next book if you buy it?

By the way, I hit on a neat way of indicating whether I really recommend a book to you or not; whether I’ve included the ‘add to goodreads’ button or not.  Subtle, eh?

Book Review | The Blackhouse by Peter May
Tagged on:                     

9 thoughts on “Book Review | The Blackhouse by Peter May

  • 4 February, 2017 at 9:08 am

    Hi Jemima – I was looking forward to a review that recommended the book … but 500 pages = no thank you … though as you say probably could dip into bits to get an idea of the lands and seas. It’d have been interesting to learn more about Lewis and the Outer Hebrides … but for now – no thanks …

    Good review though and your subtle take … re Goodreads – cheers Hilary

    • 4 February, 2017 at 1:12 pm

      It does paint an interesting picture of a tight-knit island community… not necessarily a good one. The windswept landscape is nicely described. The trip to the other end of the island to interview someone was probably the most enjoyable bit of travelogue – that and the problems of landing on an isolated bird-rock in a storm. 😉

  • 4 February, 2017 at 11:48 pm

    😂😂 In this genre the main character ALWAYS has a dark past! At least now you can happily cross this author off your TBR, which is always a bonus, I find. I’ve just read a book with similar use of bizarrely shocking and graphic descriptions of violence and such, nestled in between otherwise only mildly psychologically scarring material. It’s a bit of an unpleasant jolt to come across, I agree.

  • 4 February, 2017 at 11:50 pm

    Aaah! I’ve just noticed you’re reading Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows. I wanted to request that one but it was UK only. Bloody colonialists! 😉 Hope it’s good.

    • 5 February, 2017 at 8:59 pm

      I hope it meets my expectations and I’m not in for a nasty shock. I dare say they’ll be looking for the colonial view in a few months 😉

  • 5 February, 2017 at 3:01 am

    Thanks for taking one for the team. I’m always happy to not have to read a 500 page tome.

  • 6 February, 2017 at 2:40 pm

    Five hundred pages? Wow! As an anatomist the grisly parts don’t affect me the same way as a normal reader, but the length would. I have taken to including a first chapter of my next book at the end of each new one, as a way to entice the reader. I figure by the time the next book is out, the reader will have forgotten anyway!

Comments are closed.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers: